Skip to main content
Foot Ankle Lower Limb — foot and ankle surgery and podiatry, Perth

Toes and forefootGuide

Plantar plate tear

A plantar plate tear is damage to the ligament under the base of a toe, most often the 2nd toe, and it causes pain in the ball of the foot. Simple care such as taping, supportive shoes and padded insoles comes first, and early assessment matters.

Reviewed by Andrew Schox, BSc(Hons) PGradDipPod MPodLast reviewed 27 October 2026 6 min read

Jump to a section
  1. 1. What is a plantar plate tear, and how common is it?
  2. 2. What causes it, and who gets it?
  3. 3. What does it feel like, and how is it diagnosed?
  4. 4. What helps first?
  5. 5. What helps if that isn't enough?
  6. 6. How long does it take, and how can I stop it coming back?
  7. 7. When to see a podiatrist

At a glance

  • It's a ligament injury: the plantar plate sits under the base of a toe, most often the 2nd toe.
  • Pain is in the ball of the foot, and the toe may drift upwards or start to claw.
  • Simple care comes first: taping, supportive shoes, padded insoles and activity changes.
  • Early care matters: an untreated tear can lead to a deformed toe.

What is a plantar plate tear, and how common is it?

The plantar plate is a strong band of tissue under the joints at the base of your toes. It anchors the toes down and stops them drifting upwards. A plantar plate tear is damage to this ligament, either partial or all the way through. Any toe can be affected, but the 2nd toe is most often involved.

Doctors may also call it lesser metatarsophalangeal joint instability. It's described as a common cause of forefoot pain, although how many people are affected isn't clear yet. It's often missed because the symptoms look like other causes of pain in the ball of the foot.

What causes it, and who gets it?

Most tears develop slowly as repeated strain wears and weakens the plate, although a sudden injury can cause one. Listed risk factors include a recent change in activity such as running or jumping, foot mechanics that put extra load on the plate, and high-heeled shoes.

For forefoot pain in general, narrow or thin-soled shoes, bunions, hammer toes, long periods of standing or walking, inflammatory arthritis and past foot injuries are also listed. If you run or jump, build up gradually. See a podiatrist or your GP if you have a bunion, hammer toes or arthritis and develop forefoot pain.

What does it feel like, and how is it diagnosed?

A tear typically causes pain in the ball of the foot that comes on gradually, often with swelling. The pain is usually at the 2nd toe joint, and you may notice it when you push up onto your toes, or feel as if you're walking on a stone. The 2nd toe may drift upwards or sideways, or suddenly start to claw. Redness can also occur.

A podiatrist or doctor will ask how and when it started, look at your toes, and test the toe joint by hand (the drawer test) to check how stable it is. An MRI scan is used if the diagnosis is still in doubt. Several other conditions can cause similar pain, so see a podiatrist or your GP rather than guess the cause.

What helps first?

Simple care comes first. These steps are widely recommended, though it isn't clear yet which helps most.

  • Tape the toe down. Taping can offload the plantar plate and stop the toe drifting upwards. If it's done early, it may let the plate heal without the toe changing position. A podiatrist or physiotherapist can show you how.
  • Take pressure off the ball of your foot. Simple padded insoles and metatarsal pads can often reduce pain, and you can buy them at a pharmacy. If they don't help, a podiatrist can provide something designed for you.
  • Choose firm, supportive shoes. A firm trainer or walking boot suits best. Avoid high heels and very soft, unsupportive shoes.
  • Stretch your calves. This can reduce pressure on the ball of the foot when you walk.

What helps if that isn't enough?

If simple care isn't helping, the diagnosis is unclear or symptoms are getting worse, ask your GP or podiatrist about further assessment. Splinting, offloading and injections can ease symptoms, but they stop being effective once the problem is advanced.

Steroid injections can reduce inflammation, but they're also linked with further weakening of the ligaments that hold the toe joint steady. Ask about this before agreeing to one. Surgery may also be discussed. If it is, ask about the risks and benefits and how long recovery may take. It isn't clear yet when surgery is better than carrying on with non-surgical care.

How long does it take, and how can I stop it coming back?

Getting it assessed early can improve the chance of avoiding surgery. Early care, with the joint immobilised first and then a gradual return to activity using taping and pads, can help people get back to their previous activity level. Waiting can let pain and deformity progress. An untreated tear can lead to a deformed toe, and a dislocated toe can become arthritic and harder to realign with surgery.

How long recovery takes without surgery, and how often tears come back, isn't clear yet. Sensible steps are to return to running or jumping gradually, use taping or pads if a clinician advises, and keep wearing supportive shoes after the pain settles.

When to see a podiatrist

See your GP or a podiatrist the same day if:

  • you have diabetes and notice a wound, sore, blister or colour change on your foot;
  • you have spreading redness, heat, swelling or pus in your foot;
  • after an injury you can't put weight on your foot, or you have severe pain, swelling and bruising and can't move it well, which can mean a broken bone or torn tendon.

For urgent advice when it isn't an emergency, call healthdirect on 1800 022 222 (24 hours a day), or go to a Medicare Urgent Care Clinic.

See a podiatrist or your GP if your pain stops you doing normal activities, is getting worse or keeps coming back, hasn't improved after 2 weeks of home care, or comes with tingling or loss of feeling. See your GP or a podiatrist if you have diabetes and foot pain. See a podiatrist or your GP if you have ongoing pain under a toe, or a toe that's drifting or clawing, because an untreated tear can lead to a deformed toe.

Common questions

Can a plantar plate tear heal on its own?

Rest, taping and supportive shoes, started early, may let the plate heal without the toe changing position. Waiting without care risks the toe drifting or clawing. Because other conditions cause similar pain, it's worth having a podiatrist or GP confirm what's going on and guide your first steps.

How is a plantar plate tear different from Morton's neuroma?

Both can cause pain in the ball of the foot, and the two can look alike. Morton's neuroma is a nerve problem that can bring redness, swelling and dull aching pain. A hands-on assessment by a podiatrist or doctor is needed to tell them apart, so avoid guessing from symptoms alone.

Which scan do I need for forefoot pain?

Not everyone needs one. The diagnosis is mostly made from your history and a hands-on exam. An X-ray is used if a bone problem is suspected, and an ultrasound if the joint capsule or inflammation is the concern. An MRI helps when the diagnosis is still in doubt.

Further reading

Want to know more? Plantar plate tear on Clindice

Reviewed by Andrew Schox, BSc(Hons) PGradDipPod MPod

Podiatrist

Reviewed 27 October 2026. Next review by 27 October 2027.

How we write and review Learn

Was this page helpful?

Related guides

GuideBig toe painBig toe pain is pain in or around the big toe joint. Common causes are arthritis of the joint, gout, bunions and irritation of the small bones under the toe. Roomier shoes, adjusting activity and simple pain relief are the usual first steps, and a podiatrist can help find the cause.GuideFreiberg's diseaseFreiberg's disease is a rare condition in which the blood supply to the end of a toe bone is disrupted, causing pain in the ball of the foot, most often behind the second toe. It mostly affects teenage girls and young women. Most people start with taking pressure off the area; surgery is rarely needed.GuideClaw toeClaw toe is a curling of the smaller toes, where the toe bends up at its base and down further along. Wider, deeper shoes with a soft upper, plus pads, are the usual first steps. Surgery is kept for toes that don't improve.

Sources

(13)
  1. 1.Plantar Plate injuryNHS
  2. 2.Plantar Plate InjuryNHS
  3. 3.High-Resolution Imaging of the Plantar Plate of the Foot: Ultrasound and 3D MR Imaging EvaluationKalia V, Obanor O, Duarte Silva F · Radiologic Clinics of North America · 2026
  4. 4.Pain in your toe or the ball of your foot - MetatarsalgiaBradford District Care NHS Foundation Trust · 2025
  5. 5.Clinical examination of plantar plate abnormality: a diagnostic perspectiveKlein EE, Weil L, Weil LS et al. · Foot & Ankle International · 2013
  6. 6.Forefoot pathologiesNHS
  7. 7.Lesser Metatarsophalangeal Instability: Diagnosis and Conservative Management of a Common Cause of MetatarsalgiaKinter CW, Hodgkins CW · Sports Health · 2020
  8. 8.Metatarsophalangeal joint stability: a systematic review on the plantar plate of the lesser toesMaas NMG, van der Grinten M, Bramer WM et al. · Journal of Foot and Ankle Research · 2016
  9. 9.Nonoperative Treatment of Plantar Plate TearsMalani K, Ravine M, Schneider HP · Clinics in Podiatric Medicine and Surgery · 2022
  10. 10.Lesser Metatarsophalangeal Joint Instability: Nonsurgical Treatment AlternativesTalusan PG · Foot and Ankle Clinics · 2024
  11. 11.Metatarsalgia and dislocated toe deformitiesChelsea and Westminster Hospital NHS Foundation Trust
  12. 12.Pain in the ball of the footNHS
  13. 13.Pain in the top of the footNHS

This page is general information, not a diagnosis or a treatment plan for you. For advice about your own feet or legs, see a podiatrist or your doctor. In an emergency, call 000.

Searching…