Jump to a section
At a glance
- It's a loose label for pain, stiffness or instability in the joint just beneath the ankle, where the ankle bone meets the heel bone.
- Injury is the most common cause: fractures, dislocations and ankle sprains that leave the joint unstable.
- Giving way, rolling over and pain on uneven ground are typical, and careful questioning and examination guide the diagnosis.
- Care starts without surgery: activity changes, well-fitted cushioned shoes, insoles or supports, and taking weight off the foot for a while.
- Fusion surgery is kept for when those steps don't give enough relief, and it carries real risks.
What is subtalar joint dysfunction?
Subtalar joint dysfunction is a loose label for problems in the subtalar joint. This is the joint just beneath your ankle, where the underside of the talus (an ankle bone) meets the heel bone (the calcaneus)1. It gives your foot sideways movement and flexibility, especially on uneven ground1. Its structure varies a lot from person to person, and how much it contributes to heel and ankle problems is still debated2.
There's no single agreed definition. Related problems include hindfoot arthritis (arthritis in the back of the foot), tarsal coalition (two or more foot bones joined together abnormally)3 and sinus tarsi pain. "Sinus tarsi syndrome" is a catch-all term for pain in that area, with many possible causes4.
How common subtalar joint dysfunction is on its own isn't clear yet. For context, 9–15% of adults report ankle pain, which is often linked with osteoarthritis, though that doesn't point to this joint specifically5. This guide is about adults; children aren't covered.
What causes it, and who gets it?
Most often it follows an injury. Subtalar osteoarthritis is most commonly posttraumatic, often after a fracture of the talus or heel bone, a dislocation of the joint, or instability5. Instability means the ligaments and tendons that hold the joints in place aren't doing their job5. Ankle sprains can also leave the subtalar joint unstable and cause lasting problems2. Arthritis that follows an injury tends to cause symptoms at a younger age5.
Other causes include inflammatory arthritis such as rheumatoid arthritis, ankylosing spondylitis and psoriatic arthritis1, generalised osteoarthritis, and infection6. Foot deformity such as flat foot or clubfoot can also wear the joint6. Tarsal coalition is generally present from birth, with some forms developing after trauma or inflammatory disease3.
What does it feel like, how is it diagnosed, and when is it serious?
It usually shows up as pain and tenderness around the hindfoot or the sinus tarsi area4. If the joint is unstable, you may notice a sense of giving way, with pain, stiffness and swelling that are worse with sport and on uneven ground. It can follow one rolling injury or several repeated ones5. With hindfoot arthritis, pain is the commonest symptom. It's usually worse with walking and may disturb sleep, and stiffness is often worst first thing in the morning in inflammatory arthritis1. Tarsal coalition often causes no obvious symptoms; when it does, there can be a bony lump on the inner ankle, pain on walking and reduced movement in the joint7.
Because sinus tarsi pain has so many possible causes, diagnosis rests on a detailed history and examination, and no single special test has been described for it4. Scans don't settle it either: no current imaging can reliably predict subtalar instability, and telling it apart from chronic lateral ankle instability (repeated giving way on the outer side of the ankle) is difficult8. A diagnosis is made only after all the findings are reasoned through9.
What features can mark it as more serious?
Most people with foot and ankle pain don't have a serious cause. Red flags are prompts that raise suspicion when several occur together; they don't confirm anything9. Night pain can come with hindfoot arthritis, but it's also on lists of more serious features, so it isn't assumed to be simple arthritis19. The features described include:
- A past history of cancer, unexplained weight loss, night or non-mechanical pain, pain lasting over three months or getting worse, and fever or night sweats. These can mean a tumour, infection or inflammatory disease rather than a mechanical joint problem910.
- Pain after a fall or injury, visible deformity, major loss of movement with difficulty putting weight on the foot, or sudden swelling, redness and warmth with fever. These can mean a fracture, dislocation or infection11.
- Sudden severe pain in one joint with swelling, skin colour change, and feeling unwell with a high temperature, which suggests septic arthritis (an infected joint)9.
- Calf swelling with a red, hot, painful limb or a dusky red or purple foot, which suggests a deep vein thrombosis (a blood clot)9. A hot, red, very swollen calf with a high temperature is listed too12.
- A red, hot, swollen foot with nerve damage, unexpected pain or a sudden change in foot shape, which suggests Charcot neuroarthropathy (a serious change in the bones and joints of a foot with nerve damage)9.
- Sudden flat foot or collapse of the arch, a previous complex fracture or bone infection (osteomyelitis), or a wound that isn't healing13.
- Changes in foot sensation or shape, tingling or loss of feeling, loss of power (such as being unable to lift the foot or tripping often), a skin rash, discolouration, ulceration or signs of infection, and changes in walking ability1012. Diabetes is also listed among these features12.
Other problems that can look similar include sinus tarsi pain, chronic lateral ankle instability8, and tarsal coalition, which is often missed or wrongly treated because it's uncommon and starts gradually7.
What helps first?
Most hindfoot arthritis is first managed without surgery1. Simple steps include:
- Rest and adjust activity. Rest when pain demands it, slow down and adjust sporting activities1.
- Footwear and insoles. Well-fitted shoes with some cushioning may help foot pain, and insoles may help if your arches are particularly high or low10. Supportive boots and walking sticks are described as useful, and splints or braces can sometimes help1.
- Short-term support. Strapping or a support, a stick or crutches to take weight off the foot for a while, and regular breaks can help early on10.
- The POLICE approach (Protect, optimal Loading, Ice, Compression, Elevate) is also used for hindfoot problems14.
- Weight. For people carrying extra weight, losing weight is described as the most effective non-operative step for hindfoot arthritis1.
A steroid injection is another option; some hospitals try insoles and injections first, for positioning and pain relief, before considering surgery6. These steps are widely used, but how well each works for subtalar joint problems isn't clear yet. When they aren't working, checks for the more serious features above are repeated9.
What helps if that isn't enough?
The main option described is subtalar fusion (arthrodesis), an operation that joins the bones of the joint. It's considered when insoles and steroid injections haven't given satisfactory relief6. The research on the different surgical approaches is low-level, and better trials are needed to show whether one technique is better than another1516. How long to keep trying non-surgical care before considering surgery isn't clear yet.
Fusion carries real risks. About 1% of fusions lead to a bone infection, which is serious and may need further surgery. About 10% don't heal properly (non-union), and the bones have to be fused again with another operation6. After foot surgery, pain, swelling or bleeding that continues despite raising the leg and taking painkillers can mean early infection or a deep vein thrombosis1.
How long does it take, what affects recovery, and can it come back?
How it goes depends on the cause and how severe it is, and the clearest information is about injuries. After a closed subtalar dislocation towards the inside of the foot (medial) with no fracture, care without surgery gave favourable long-term function. That care was prompt closed reduction (putting the joint back in place without an operation), a short period of immobilisation and structured rehabilitation17. Reduced movement in the joint was still common, and early movement was linked with better preserved motion17.
Dislocations towards the outside (lateral), open injuries and injuries with a fracture consistently have worse outcomes. For lateral dislocations an early surgical opinion can be justified, even when the joint goes back in17.
After a heel bone fracture, results are worse with open fractures, repair delayed beyond 14 days, a high body mass index and smoking17. Restoring the joint surface and the shape of the heel bone also matters17. These are links with outcome, not proof of cause.
What helps prevent subtalar joint dysfunction coming back isn't clear yet.
Common questions
Is subtalar joint dysfunction the same as subtalar arthritis?
Not exactly. Subtalar joint dysfunction is a loose label for problems of the joint beneath the ankle, with no single agreed definition. Subtalar arthritis is one of those problems. It most often follows an injury, such as a fracture or dislocation, but inflammatory arthritis, infection and generalised osteoarthritis can also cause it.
How is subtalar instability different from a normal ankle sprain?
Ankle sprains are the main cause of ankle instability, and in some people the lasting problem comes from the subtalar joint rather than the ankle joint itself. The two are hard to tell apart, and scans can't reliably predict subtalar instability, so a detailed history and careful examination matter, including when the foot gives way and any past injuries.
Do I need an X-ray, CT or MRI for hindfoot pain?
Diagnosis rests mainly on a detailed history and examination. Plain X-rays are the imaging used most often when subtalar instability is suspected, but no imaging method can reliably predict it, so scans don't replace the examination. Because sinus tarsi pain has many possible causes, the whole picture is considered before a diagnosis is made.
Further reading
Want to know more? Subtalar joint dysfunction on Clindice
Reviewed by Andrew Schox, BSc(Hons) PGradDipPod MPod
Podiatrist
Reviewed 22 November 2026. Next review by 22 November 2027.
Related guides
Sources
(17)
- 1.Hind foot arthritiswsh.nhs.uk
- 2.The subtalar joint: A complex mechanismKrähenbühl N, Horn-Lang T, Hintermann B et al. · EFORT Open Reviews · 2017
- 3.Tarsal coalition in adultsMehdi N, Bernasconi A, Lintz F · Orthopaedics & Traumatology, Surgery & Research · 2024
- 4.The Evolution of Sinus Tarsi Syndrome-What Is the Underlying Pathology?-A Critical ReviewWillegger M, Bouchard M, Schwarz GM et al. · Journal of Clinical Medicine · 2023
- 5.Imaging of osteoarthritis from the ankle through the midfootOmar IM, Weaver JS, Altbach MI et al. · Skeletal Radiology · 2023
- 6.Subtalar Joint FusionMallard A · Royal Orthopaedic Hospital
- 7.Expert consensus on the clinical diagnosis and management of Talocalcaneal coalition (2025 Edition)Hu Y, Ma X · Zhonghua Yi Xue Yi Chuan Xue Za Zhi = Zhonghua Yixue Yichuanxue Zazhi = Chinese Journal of Medical Genetics · 2025
- 8.Currently used imaging options cannot accurately predict subtalar joint instabilityKrähenbühl N, Weinberg MW, Davidson NP et al. · Knee Surgery, Sports Traumatology, Arthroscopy · 2019
- 9.Red flagsNHS
- 10.Foot and ankleHampshire and Isle of Wight Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust
- 11.Foot and Ankle PainLeicestershire Partnership NHS Trust · 2026
- 12.Foot and ankle painNHS
- 13.Hindfoot problemsNHS
- 14.Systematic Review of Subtalar Distraction Arthrodesis for the Treatment of Subtalar ArthritisFletcher AN, Liles JL, Steele JJ et al. · Foot & Ankle International · 2020
- 15.Inconclusive evidence that arthroscopic techniques yield better outcomes than open techniques for subtalar arthrodesis-A systematic reviewSilvampatti SR, Dsouza TDL, Ramakanth R et al. · Journal of ISAKOS · 2023
- 16.Conservative Outcomes of Subtalar Dislocation: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of the Current LiteratureBakr A, Yusuf Y, Tahoun M et al. · Journal of Foot and Ankle Research · 2026
- 17.Calcaneus fractures: facts, controversies and recent developmentsRammelt S, Zwipp H · Injury · 2004
This is general information, not advice about your own situation. To discuss your issues, book with one of our podiatrists. In an emergency, call 000.
